I think we’re at a tipping point, and a lot of it really does come down to volume. With Hasbro as the main example, I put the number at roughly 120 to 150 Marvel or Star Wars figures per year. At an average of thirty dollars a figure going into 2027, you do the math. That’s $3,600 to $4,500 a year if you’re buying that many, before tax, and that’s a lot of money to put into a hobby.
It was already a lot of money when figures were $19.99 five years ago. Going from $19.99 to thirty dollars is an increase of roughly fifty percent, and when you look at that alongside the current cost of living, you realize that being an all-in collector is no longer possible for a lot of us. The excitement can still be there, but our ability to keep up with everything has changed.
Constantly, we’re being told to buy within our means, buy what we can, and remember that we don’t have to buy everything. But here’s the problem: these companies have spent decades establishing a particular type of toy buyer. A lot of us are between thirty-five and fifty-five, and we were conditioned in our youth to want to purchase things and collect them all. From G.I. Joe to He-Man, that idea was built into the toy lines of the eighties, long before Pokémon gave us “gotta catch ’em all.” While buying less might be an easy thing to say, it isn’t always an easy thing to do.
There’s also a culture of comparison within the community that drives our buying. I’ve heard people say they don’t compete, but showing what we have on social media or YouTube can become a form of competition, even when the intention is to share our enjoyment. We’re collecting for our own gratification, but sometimes for our status within the community, too. I think that’s part of why coming together is so difficult: our individual desire to get the next thing can get in the way of the concerns we share.
On top of that, I don’t feel that Hasbro, Mattel, and other companies are necessarily standing up for us as consumers. Practices at Walmart, Target, Amazon, and even Hasbro Pulse create fear of missing out, a frenzy, and a panic around buying things that are supposed to be fun. When getting a toy becomes something you have to keep checking on, plan around, and worry about missing, the enjoyment starts getting lost.



Going into stores has become its own kind of work. Unless you’re making daily trips around your area, learning how those stores operate, and figuring out which questions to ask, you can feel like you’re already behind. Between product numbers, DPCIs, and different terminology for how merchandise is packed and handled, just knowing how to have the conversation takes effort. Meanwhile, fewer stores are carrying the products, the sections we shop are getting smaller, and prices keep going up.
What gets lost in all of this is the simple impulse purchase. There have been plenty of times over the past twenty years when I’ve walked into a store and said, “I think this looks cool. I’m going to give it a shot,” or noticed a part I could use for something else. Seeing the size, scale, color, and design in person makes a difference. I once bought a hamster with a laptop and a computer because it was the right size for a diorama, and I wouldn’t have done that if I hadn’t seen it in the store.
That’s the tipping point I’m talking about: the toy companies themselves are pushing us out the door. We can no longer support them one hundred percent like we used to, because the money that once stretched across Marvel Legends, Star Wars Black Series, and Transformers doesn’t go nearly as far. It feels like I could once get a dozen toys for what I’m going to pay for six in the coming year.
So we have to become more discerning in our tastes and more selective about what we buy. Mythic Legions figures are beautiful, and while they’re not as articulated as I might like, I’ll be damned if I’m not willing to pay fifty dollars for one with everything included in the box when I compare it to a thirty-dollar retro-carded X-Men figure that barely has any accessories.
I’m still willing to spend money on toys, but I need to see the value in what I’m buying. And I think the saddest part is that, even with so many of us feeling that same frustration, we’re still struggling to come together as a community long enough to do something about it.
So when we look at this tipping point, the question keeps coming up: will action figures be around in ten, twenty, or thirty years? I honestly don’t know. If the companies keep going the way they are, they’ll probably keep trying to sell them, because I don’t feel they’re listening to us as consumers. But if our buying habits drive what gets made, then if we don’t buy it, they’re not going to make it.
I think it’s a real possibility that mass-market, big-box-store lines like Marvel Legends, Black Series, and Transformers could slowly die off and be replaced on those shelves by more manageable, budget-friendly lines around these characters. That’s what I think parents are going to buy their kids. They’re not just buying a thirty-dollar Spider-Man, because their kid is going to want a villain to go along with it. Given that choice, I think parents will go for the cheaper figures.
And we’re looking for cheaper options, too. We’re waiting for sales and not buying as much, while the companies don’t have the outlets they used to have to reach us. We’re seeing more made-to-order offerings and requests for payment up front, which changes how we buy again.
When I think about the future, I wonder whether this era of collecting will become a snapshot in history. I think it’s going to slow down and radically change, and I don’t know what will become of it.
If getting the next figure matters more than coming together as a community, then we’re helping keep the very thing we’re complaining about going.
